Comparison of Emeralds from the Chitral District, Pakistan, with other Pakistani and Afghan Emeralds

Comparison of Emeralds from the Chitral District, Pakistan, with other Pakistani and Afghan Emeralds" by Hanser et al. (2023), suitable for gemology students:

---

🔷 Origin and Location

• Emerald Deposit: Chitral District, north-western Pakistan (discovered in 2021)

• Geological Zone: Outside the traditional “Emerald Belt” (Indus Suture Zone)

• Host Rocks: Quartz- and mica-rich metapelites of the Arkari Formation, intruded by pegmatitic leucogranite

---

🪨 Rock Types and Formation

• Chitral emeralds form in schist-hosted environments

• Hosted in quartz- and mica-rich metamorphic rocks

• Similar to emeralds in Afghanistan's Panjshir and Swat (Pakistan), but geochemically distinct

---

🎨 Color and Diaphaneity

• Colors: Light green to dark green

• Transparency: Mostly transparent; higher-quality than earlier samples

• Notable: Deeper-colored samples show potential for gem trade

---

🔍 Inclusions

• Chitral Inclusions:

  • Two-phase inclusions (gas + liquid)

  • Hollow growth tubes (some with yellowish precipitates)

  • Surface-reaching inclusions: quartz, plagioclase (andesine/oligoclase), K-feldspar, phlogopite (main dark mica), rare muscovite

• No three-phase inclusions, which is key to distinguishing from Panjshir, Swat, and Laghman emeralds

• Laghman: Biotite and three-phase inclusions

• Swat: Black opaque minerals (spinel, pyrite), talc, carbonate, and mica

---

🔬 Optical & Physical Properties

Property	Chitral Emeralds
Refractive Index	1.580–1.590
Birefringence	0.008–0.009
SG	2.71–2.74
UV-Vis-NIR	Strong Fe²⁺ absorption (~830 nm)
Raman Spectra	Strong Type II H₂O peaks

---

🧪 Chemical Composition (Major/Trace Elements)

By EPMA (Oxides, wt.%):

• SiO₂: ~63.6–64.4%

• Al₂O₃: ~15.3–16.1%

• FeO: ~0.45–0.63%

• MgO: ~1.6–1.9%

• Na₂O: ~1.5%

• BeO: Fixed ~13.6%

By LA-ICP-MS (ppm):

• High in:

  • Li: 938–1359 ppm (significantly higher than Swat, Panjshir, Laghman)

  • Cs: Up to 5782 ppm

  • Na: ~11,000–12,000 ppm

  • Mg: ~9,000–11,000 ppm

• Low in:

  • Mn: ~15–26 ppm

  • Ti: ~11–18 ppm

  • Zn: ~13–18 ppm

---

💡 Cause of Color

• Chromophores: Chromium (Cr), Vanadium (V), and Iron (Fe)

• Chitral emeralds show:

  • Fe²⁺ dominant (responsible for bluish-green tone)

  • Moderate Cr and V contents

• Fe₂⁺ feature in UV-Vis (~830 nm) is stronger than Cr³⁺ and V³⁺, indicating schist-hosted genesis

---

🧬 Elements (in ppm)

Element	Range	Characteristic
Li	938–1359	High – diagnostic for Chitral
Cs	1151–5782	High – separates from Swat
Cr	514–1197	Color contributor
V	222–391	Color contributor
Na	~11,000–12,000	Higher than Khaltaro
Fe	~3413–4164	Bluish-green tint source

---

🔎 Diagnostic Features for Origin Determination

Property	Chitral vs Others
Inclusions	No three-phase; phlogopite-rich
Fe²⁺ Absorption	Stronger than Cr³⁺ & V³⁺
Li & Cs Levels	Significantly higher
Water Type (Raman)	Dominant Type II H₂O peaks
Growth Features	Weak zoning; no sawtooth structures

---

📍 Summary for Students

• Chitral emeralds are schist-hosted, Fe²⁺-rich, and alkali-rich

• No three-phase inclusions (unlike Panjshir or Swat)

• High levels of Li and Cs make them chemically distinct

• Excellent for origin studies due to inclusion types, spectroscopic patterns, and chemical profiles

• Increasing mining activity in Chitral makes identification increasingly important in gem markets